Gary Marcus critiques Matt Shumer’s viral blog post with nearly 50 million views, calling it hype with misleading claims about AI’s coding capabilities. He argues that Shumer’s assertions lack data and ignore issues like error rates and user experiences. Marcus highlights five points of concern, including potential user burnout and security risks of AI-generated code, while cautioning against overconfidence in AI’s reliability. He concludes that despite some improvements, Shumer’s perspective is overly optimistic and unrealistic.
https://garymarcus.substack.com/p/about-that-matt-shumer-post-that